| Abraham Busenitz (1739–1787) | '1739–1787' from the census comments; too close to daughter Anna's 1744 birth — may be a different Abraham, or the years mean something else | strong inference |
| Alvin C. Ramseyer Sr. (1880–1948) | Find a Grave header gives death 23 Aug 1948, Wooster — error for 23 July 1948 at sea (obituaries and family tree) | documented |
| Andrew J. Neuenschwander (1888–1972) | Birth 4 Nov 1888 (newspaper, Find a Grave, SSDI) vs 4 Dec (The Mennonite) — prefer 4 Nov, Death Wed 19 Apr 1972 (MWR, Find a Grave) vs 20 Apr (The Mennonite) | documented |
| Anna Busenitz (1744–1797) | Possibly a confusion with Maria Busenitz, Anton Fieguth's first wife (m. 1800), Father's dates '1739–1787' (census note) make him only 5 years older than Anna (b. 1744) — the note may give marriage/other years; check GRANDMA #317726 | compiled lead |
| Anna Hochstetler (killed 1757) | Maiden name: Lorentz (1912 book, Wikipedia, 1986 booklet) vs Burki, daughter of Christian Burki (AMC genealogy) vs unknown (JHFA), Whether she was the mother of John (b. c.1730) or a later wife | unresolved |
| Anna Maria Lehman (1825–1886) | Birth 25 Feb 1825 (Langnau register) vs 23 Feb (headstone), Death 1886 (headstone) vs 1889 (Snow 1907) | documented |
| Aron J. Wiebe (1845–1922) | Find a Grave: born 'in Russia' — Reid tree, amtrakt.de and his 1922 obituary: Altenau, West Prussia, Emigration: 1894 (vault, from family trees) vs spring 1896 to Beatrice, then October 1897 to Paso Robles (1922 obituary; MHB 2007) | documented |
| Barbara Kaufmann (1779–1844) | Birth 1779 (Staker) vs 1777 (1907 booklet, 1986 tree) | compiled lead |
| Barbara Reich (1826–1894) | Birthplace: Stark County (Staker, Find a Grave) vs 'Germany' (1850 census) | documented |
| Catharina Fuhrimann (1782–1853) | 1782–1853 and death in Ohio from a MyHeritage tree only | documented |
| Christian Daniel Miller (c.1734–1777) | Name: 'Daniel Miller' (1911/1912 books) vs Christian Miller Jr. (AAMG via WikiTree), Arrival: Patience 11 Aug 1750 (1911) vs 1760 (1912); WikiTree: Christian Jr. son of Christian Sr., Francis and Elizabeth 1742, Marriage to Veronica Mishler: in Europe (1911) vs in Pennsylvania c.1758–60 (WikiTree) | unresolved |
| Christian P. Neuenschwander (1812–1884) | Age at death: Bundesbote 1884 says 71 y 8 m 5 d (implying birth c. 28 Feb – 1 Mar 1813), not 71 y 11 m 13 d as 23 Nov 1812 would give, Death 1884 (headstone) vs 1887 (Snow 1907) — prefer headstone, The Amish periodical *The Diary* (Adams County list) has 'Mrs. Christian P. Neuenschwander, Berne R2' on 13 Nov 1885 and 'Christian P. Neuenschwander, Berne R2' on 5 Jul 1889; probably a different (Amish) couple of the same name, unverified, Birth 23 Nov 1812 (Täufer register, headstone) vs 23 Dec 1812 (1844 Langnau marriage entry), Marriage place: Tramelan in compiled tree — the 1844 entry gives an Anabaptist preacher; place still to read, Birthplace 'Bern' = canton; Geneanet lead 'Höfen, 1811' unconfirmed | documented |
| Christina Gerig (1832–1909) | Birth year 1832 (obituary) vs 1831 (family tree) | documented |
| D. Paul Miller (1917–2018) | Marriage 14 Aug 1948 (obituary) vs 'Aug 1947' (Anne's Find a Grave text) | documented |
| Daniel Ramseyer (1856–1942) | Birth year: 1856 (vault) vs 30 Jul 1853 (History of Wayne County 1910, p. 985), 1910 county history: born 1853, married 1875 — obituaries: born 1856, married 11 Oct 1877 (prefer obituaries), Earlier AI research: died 1941, born in Illinois, mother Verena Zug — all wrong (obituary) | documented |
| David Schrock (1858–1903) | Death 10 Aug 1903 (Find a Grave, 1912 book, 1986 history) vs 17 Aug (Fanny's 1942 obituary) — prefer 10 Aug, Marriage 16 Dec 1880 (1912 book) vs 18 Dec 1881 (Fanny's obituary) | documented |
| Fanny H. Plank (1857–1942) | Birth 23 Feb (obituary) vs 22 Feb (1912 book) | documented |
| Gerhard Fieguth (1823–1896) | Birthplace Koczelitzke (amtrakt.de) vs Warnau (Reid tree) | compiled lead |
| Grace Melvine Yoder (1881–1907) | Birth 31 Jan (Find a Grave) vs 30 Jan (family tree) | documented |
| Jacob C. Neuenschwander (1848–1921) | Death 25 Feb (Find a Grave) vs 26 Feb 1921 (certificate abstract) | documented |
| Jacob Hochstetler (1712–1776) | Immigration: 1736 on the Harle (1912 book) — a different Jacob (b. 1704, wife Eva); ancestor came on the Charming Nancy 9 Nov 1738, aged 26, Attack date: 19 Sept 1757 (Fort Allen report) vs 29 Sept, 30 Sept–1 Oct, 12 Oct, 20 Nov in other sources | documented |
| Jacob Mast (1738–1808) | Father unknown: 'Christen or Ulrich' (WikiTree) vs Jacob Mast × Barbara Berkey (Geni), Magdalena's father: Michael Holly (1911 book) vs Johannes Hooley (Mast Family Stories) | compiled lead |
| Jakob Reusser (1840–1916) | Memorial flags itself as a possible duplicate (a 'sibling' Jacob with identical dates) | compiled lead |
| Johann Fieguth (1707–1780) | Not in the 1776 Mennonite census under any spelling, though alive until 1780 | documented |
| Johannes Neuenschwander (1776–1838) | — | documented |
| Johannes Ramseyer (1780–1853) | Birth: 1780 (Staker, French records) vs 'Eckenweil, Canton Berne, 1776' (1907 booklet), Birthplace: Mancenans, France (2002 Family Record) vs Eckenweil/Eggiwil (1907 booklet); Staker places the family in Neuchâtel (Le Locle) around 1780 | documented |
| John Hochstetler (c.1735–1805) | Mother: whether the Anna killed in 1757 was his mother or a stepmother is unknown | documented |
| Joseph Hochstetler (c.1746–1812) | Birth given as 1742, 1744 or 1746, Who was shot at the door: Joseph (Wikipedia) or Jacob Jr. (1912 preface), Death 24 Aug 1812 vs c.1823 in some summaries | compiled lead |
| Maggie Mae Kuhns (1890–1970) | Birth 6 Apr 1890 (obituary, 1912 book) vs 2 May 1890 (Find a Grave — confused with D. D.'s birthday), Surviving sister 'Lula Klinglesmith' (1970 obituary) matches none of Magdalena's children | documented |
| Maria Fieguth (1847–1890) | Death 1890 (Dyck diary, 19 Aug old style = 31 Aug new style) vs 1891 (Find a Grave) vs 1892 (Gerhard's obituary) — prefer 1890 | documented |
| Maria Thüler (fl. 1782) | Surname reading uncertain: Thüler / Schüler | documented |
| Mary Ellen Schrock (1886–1972) | Death: 20 Dec 1973 (Gospel Herald, a typo) vs 21 Dec 1972 (Find a Grave, family tree); age 86y 6m 4d fits Dec 1972, Find a Grave birthplace 'Wayne County, Indiana' — error for Wayne County, Ohio | documented |
| Michael Schrock (1782–1860) | Marriage 1828 in Somerset County (1986 history) conflicts with son Stephen's 1811 birth — 1808 or earlier likely | compiled lead |
| Moses Schrock (1828–1909) | Birth 10 June (obituary) vs 5 June (Find a Grave) | documented |
| Nancy Hostetler (1836–1860) | Burial: Oak Grove (Find a Grave) vs Amish Plank ('President's') Cemetery north of Wooster (1986 history, Geni) | documented |
| Nathan Smiley (1797–1872) | Death: 9 May 1872 (Herald of Truth 1872 death notice) vs 9 Mar 1872 (vault); age 74 y 10 m 22 d implies birth c. 17 Jun 1797, not 16 Apr 1797, First wife: Anna Stutzman (family 1986, vault) vs Anna Miller (Mennonite Historical Bulletin 2006), 1986 tree names his wife (John's mother) 'Margaretha Miller' — John's obituary says Anna; Margaret/Rebecca Margaret Miller was his 2nd wife (m. 1831) | family compilation |
| Peter Ramseyer (1822–1880) | Birth day: 5 Nov 1822 (French civil index via Staker) vs 5 Oct (headstone), Arrival: 1834 (county history, 1986 booklet) vs 5 July 1835 (Richmond passenger list) — prefer 1835 | documented |
| Samuel Kuhns (1843–1918) | Birth year 1843 (obituary) vs c.1840 (Byler 1993; an online tree gives 20 Jul 1840) — his mother reportedly died Jan 1842, Marriage 1863 (his obituary) vs 1864 (hers), Children: '4 sons and 6 daughters' (obituaries) vs 11 (1912 book) | documented |
| Susanna Yoder (1791–1855) | Death 1855 (Find a Grave) vs 1848 as read on the family tree | compiled lead |
| The Neuenschwanders of the Jura | — | — |